Skip to content
The Burger Index
Rank your burgers
The Burger Index
Neighborhood ·Staten Island

Westerleigh

2 priced menus here: 2 independent restaurants.

Median

$16.75

Index price

vs NYC

−16%

NYC median $20.00

Range

$11.50 to $22.00

Cheapest to priciest index price

Cast a line

Restaurants in Westerleigh.

Sorted by index price, cheapest first.
Restaurants in Westerleigh
RestaurantIndex price
Bagel Bistro & DinerBagel Bistro Burger Bomb$11.50
SI DinerVictory Panini$22.00

2 priced.

Not priced

  • Mother Pugs Saloon
  • The Buttery

Ask the cook

Quick answers.

How much does a burger cost in Westerleigh, Staten Island?
The median burger in Westerleigh, Staten Island, costs $16.75 (September 2026), 16% below the $20.00 NYC median.
Where are burgers cheapest in Westerleigh, Staten Island?
The priciest burger at Bagel Bistro & Diner is $11.50, the lowest top-burger price of any spot in Westerleigh, Staten Island (September 2026).
What is the most expensive burger in Westerleigh, Staten Island?
The most expensive burger in Westerleigh, Staten Island, is the Victory Panini at SI Diner, $22.00 (September 2026).

Neighborhood specials

Elsewhere in Staten Island.