Cheapest on the counter
Saucy
Smash Burgers · Grasmere-Arrochar-Ft. Wadsworth
$8.89−56% vs NYCRestaurant site
Borough
Staten Island
The Burger Index · Staten Island median
$17.00
vs NYC
−15%
NYC median $20.00
Fresh off the grill
How Staten Island prices spread.
Index prices on 35 menus
Most of these 35 index prices fall between $11 and $22; the median is $17.00.
Use the left and right arrow keys to read each bar.
| Index price | Menus | Price level |
|---|---|---|
| ≤ $9.99 | 1 | Steal |
| $10.00–$10.99 | 3 | Steal |
| $11.00–$11.99 | 2 | Steal |
| $13.00–$13.99 | 3 | Steal |
| $14.00–$14.99 | 1 | Deal |
| $15.00–$15.99 | 1 | Deal |
| $16.00–$16.99 | 6 | Deal |
| $17.00–$17.99 | 4 | Going rate |
| $18.00–$18.99 | 3 | Going rate |
| $19.00–$19.99 | 3 | Going rate |
| $20.00–$20.99 | 2 | Going rate |
| $21.00–$21.99 | 1 | Going rate |
| $22.00–$22.99 | 2 | Going rate |
| $24.00–$24.99 | 1 | Pricey |
| $28.00–$28.99 | 1 | Splurge |
| $29.00+ | 1 | Splurge |
Neighborhood specials
Staten Island neighborhoods.
Only Great Kills is ranked.
Great KillsStaten IslandMedian $18.98Range $14.95–$30.00 · 8 menus · −5% vs NYC
Other neighborhoods
- Annadale-Huguenot-Prince's Bay-Eltingville$16.29 · 1 menu
- Charleston-Richmond Valley-Tottenville$17.95 · 3 menus
- Grasmere-Arrochar-Ft. Wadsworth$8.89 · 1 menu
- New Brighton-Silver Lake$17.00 · 3 menus
- New Dorp-Midland Beach$17.75 · 4 menus
- New Springville-Bloomfield-Travis$17.60 · 4 menus
- Old Town-Dongan Hills-South Beach$10.95 · 1 menu
- Port Richmond$13.50 · 3 menus
- Rossville-Woodrow$10.95 · 1 menu
- Stapleton-Rosebank$24.00 · 1 menu
- Todt Hill-Emerson Hill-Heartland Village-Lighthouse Hill$18.00 · 2 menus
- West New Brighton-New Brighton-St. George$13.00 · 1 menu
- Westerleigh$16.75 · 2 menus
Catch of the day
The cheapest and priciest spots in Staten Island.
Cheapest burger spots
8-Bit Bites
Double Smashburger · chain, 1 Staten Island location
$10.40−48% vs NYCRestaurant siteCD Burger
Platinum Record Smash Burger · Old Town-Dongan Hills-South Beach
$10.95−45% vs NYCOnline orderingWoodrow Diner
Greek Burger · Rossville-Woodrow
$10.95−45% vs NYCRestaurant site
Most expensive burgers
Top shelf
Da Damaso
Triple Hamburger Damaso · Great Kills
$30.00+50% vs NYCRestaurant siteWest Shore Inn
The ''West Shore'' Burger · New Springville-Bloomfield-Travis
$28.00+40% vs NYCDelivery appThe Hop Shoppe
Notorious MAC Burger · Stapleton-Rosebank
$24.00+20% vs NYCOnline orderingRichmond Republic
Lux Burger · Great Kills
$22.00+10% vs NYCRestaurant site
Ask the cook
Quick answers.
- How much does a burger cost in Staten Island?
- The median burger in Staten Island costs $17.00 (September 2026), 15% below the $20.00 NYC median.
- Where are burgers cheapest in Staten Island?
- The priciest burger at Saucy in Grasmere-Arrochar-Ft. Wadsworth is $8.89, the lowest top-burger price of any spot in Staten Island (September 2026). See the cheapest burger spots in Staten Island.
- What is the most expensive burger in Staten Island?
- The most expensive burger in Staten Island is the Triple Hamburger Damaso at Da Damaso in Great Kills, $30.00 (September 2026). See the most expensive burgers in Staten Island.