Skip to content
The Burger Index
Rank your burgers
The Burger Index
Neighborhood ·Staten Island

New Brighton-Silver Lake

3 priced menus here: 3 independent restaurants.

Median

$17.00

Index price

vs NYC

−15%

NYC median $20.00

Range

$16.15 to $19.50

Cheapest to priciest index price

Cast a line

Restaurants in New Brighton-Silver Lake.

Sorted by index price, cheapest first.
Restaurants in New Brighton-Silver Lake
RestaurantIndex price
Supreme Burger CompanyCowboy Burger$16.15
Jody's Club ForestBlue Cheese Butter Burger$17.00
Duffy's TavernCustom Steakhouse Burger$19.50

3 priced.

Ask the cook

Quick answers.

How much does a burger cost in New Brighton-Silver Lake, Staten Island?
The median burger in New Brighton-Silver Lake, Staten Island, costs $17.00 (September 2026), 15% below the $20.00 NYC median.
Where are burgers cheapest in New Brighton-Silver Lake, Staten Island?
The priciest burger at Supreme Burger Company is $16.15, the lowest top-burger price of any spot in New Brighton-Silver Lake, Staten Island (September 2026).
What is the most expensive burger in New Brighton-Silver Lake, Staten Island?
The most expensive burger in New Brighton-Silver Lake, Staten Island, is the Custom Steakhouse Burger at Duffy's Tavern, $19.50 (September 2026).

Neighborhood specials

Elsewhere in Staten Island.