Restaurant
Carnegie Diner and Cafe
205 West 57 Street, Midtown-Midtown South, Manhattan.
The burger
American Wagyu pastrami, organic beef burger, Swiss cheese, caramelized onions, lettuce, tomato, mushrooms, Reuben sauce & hand-cut fries
- vs Midtown-Midtown South
- +17%
- Neighborhood median $23.00
- vs NYC
- +35%
- NYC median $20.00
Restaurant site
Prices corrected by hand · Sep 25, 2026
Nearby at a similar price.
- Brooklyn DinerBackyard BBQ Burger · 0.1 mi away$25.95
- McGee'sGuinness Wagyu Burger · 0.1 mi away$25.00
- P. McDaid's Irish PubMcdaid's Specialty Burger · 0.2 mi away$25.00
- Ellen's Stardust DinerBe Bop a Lula · 0.3 mi away$29.75
More in Midtown-Midtown South.
- The Lunch BoxCraft Your Own Double Patty$14.99
- Nomad Diner / Art NomadClassic Smash Burger$15.00
- John Sullivan's PubClassic Angus Beef Burger$17.00
- Schnipper's Quality KitchenThe Big Schnipp$17.00
- Andrew's NYC DinerBlack and Blue Burger Basket$17.50
- BurgermaniaJuicy Lucy$17.67
Run Carnegie Diner and Cafe? Get its price badge for your website.