Skip to content
The Burger Index
Rank your burgers
The Burger Index
Neighborhood ·Brooklyn

Carroll Gardens-Columbia Street-Red Hook

The Burger Index · Carroll Gardens-Columbia Street-Red Hook median

$25.00

8 menus · Updated Sep 27, 2026

vs NYC

+25%

NYC median $20.00

Range

$15.00 to $34.00

Cheapest to priciest index price

Cast a line

Restaurants in Carroll Gardens-Columbia Street-Red Hook.

Sorted by index price, cheapest first.
Restaurants in Carroll Gardens-Columbia Street-Red Hook
RestaurantIndex price
Jalopy TavernDomi Smashburger$15.00
Mex Carroll's DinerCarroll's Burger$17.00
The Long Island BarThe L. I. Burger$22.00
BIGTINYJolie Burger$24.00
Henry PublicHamburger Sandwich with cheese & bacon$26.00
Swoony'sSwoony's Burger$26.00
Cafe KestrelGrilled Burger$32.00
Red Hook TavernDry-Aged Red Hook Tavern Burger$34.00

8 priced.

Not priced

  • Cafe Spaghetti
  • Hometown Bar-B-Que
  • Luana's Tavern
  • Madcap Cafe
  • Mooburger
  • Ramblin' Chick
  • Tavern Next Door

Ask the cook

Quick answers.

How much does a burger cost in Carroll Gardens-Columbia Street-Red Hook, Brooklyn?
The median burger in Carroll Gardens-Columbia Street-Red Hook, Brooklyn, costs $25.00 (September 2026), 25% above the $20.00 NYC median.
Where are burgers cheapest in Carroll Gardens-Columbia Street-Red Hook, Brooklyn?
The priciest burger at Jalopy Tavern is $15.00, the lowest top-burger price of any spot in Carroll Gardens-Columbia Street-Red Hook, Brooklyn (September 2026).
What is the most expensive burger in Carroll Gardens-Columbia Street-Red Hook, Brooklyn?
The most expensive burger in Carroll Gardens-Columbia Street-Red Hook, Brooklyn, is the Dry-Aged Red Hook Tavern Burger at Red Hook Tavern, $34.00 (September 2026).

Neighborhood specials

Elsewhere in Brooklyn.